Skip to main content
Decision guide

IT AMC vs managed IT, and which you actually need

An AMC is a maintenance agreement covering the upkeep and repair of equipment you already own. Managed IT includes that and adds monitoring, security, Microsoft 365 administration, helpdesk and planning. If your problem is that things break and nobody fixes them fast enough, an AMC solves it. If your problem is that nobody is looking after the estate as a whole, an AMC will not.

What is actually being compared

IT AMC
Annual contract for preventive maintenance and break-fix on named equipment, with a defined response time.
Managed IT
Ongoing management of the whole estate: monitoring, patching, security, identity, helpdesk and planning.
Side by side

How they differ in practice

Feature
Feature
IT AMC
Managed IT
Hardware repair
Core of the contractIncluded
Preventive maintenance
Scheduled visits with reportsIncluded, plus continuous monitoring
Monitoring and alerting
Not usuallyCore of the contract
Patching and updates
Sometimes, on visitsScheduled and reported
Microsoft 365 administration
NoYes
Security baseline and identity
Antivirus at mostConditional access, MFA, device compliance
Backup management
Checked on visitsConfigured, monitored, restore-tested
Helpdesk for staff
Not usuallyIncluded
Planning and reporting
Asset registerQuarterly review and roadmap

An AMC is enough if

  • Your estate is mostly hardware and the software side is simple: a handful of machines, a billing or accounting package, and email you rarely think about.
  • You already have somebody handling day-to-day questions and you only need a contract for repairs and preventive work.
  • Your fleet is ageing and what you need most is predictable maintenance cost and a current asset register to plan replacement from.

Move to managed IT when

  • You have moved to Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace and nobody is administering it properly, which shows up as licence waste, orphaned accounts and no MFA.
  • A customer or an auditor has started asking questions you cannot evidence.
  • Failures are being discovered by staff rather than by monitoring, and the first sign of a problem is people unable to work.
  • You are spending more time coordinating IT than you would spend paying somebody to own it.

When the other option is right

Plenty of businesses genuinely need an AMC and nothing more, and we would rather sell that than oversell a managed contract that produces reports nobody reads. If your estate is fifteen machines running a billing package, an AMC plus a properly configured backup is the honest recommendation.

How to decide in a week

  1. List every system where an outage costs money on the day it happens. If that list is only hardware, an AMC is likely sufficient. If it includes email, identity, cloud or customer data, it is not.
  2. Check whether anybody currently administers your Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace tenant. Look at the number of global administrators, whether MFA is enforced, and how many licences are assigned to people who left.
  3. Ask when a backup was last restored, by whom, and how long it took. If nobody can answer, that gap matters more than the AMC-versus-managed question.
  4. Get both quoted from the same audit, so you are comparing scope rather than sales positioning.
  5. Start with an AMC if the honest answer is that your estate is simple. Moving up later is straightforward; paying for a managed contract nobody uses is not.
Questions

Common questions

They are not really separate purchases. A managed contract includes the maintenance an AMC provides, so you would not buy both. What some clients do is start with an AMC and add managed services for a specific area, usually Microsoft 365 or security, before moving fully.

Usually only to the extent of operating system and driver issues. Application faults inside your billing, ERP or practice software are the software vendor responsibility, though a good AMC provider will coordinate with them rather than closing the ticket as out of scope.

Both are fixed for the contract term, which is the point of each. The difference is what the fee covers: an AMC leaves you exposed to costs a managed contract absorbs, such as a security incident that nobody was monitoring for.
References

Official documentation

Still deciding?

Talk it through with an engineer, not a salesperson

Tell us your situation and we will tell you which option fits, including when that is not us. Initial reply within 4 business hours.